So, I’m guessing a few of my GDRT colleagues may write about restoration. Unfortunately, in my young career as a designer, I’ve yet to restore.
RENOVATION, on the other hand—oh, but renovation is dear to my heart. So dear, in fact, you might call me the Renovator. One of my favorite gardening terms has always been “renovation pruning.” It’s like we’re going to prune new bathroom tile out of this plant! But no, the term actually refers to the act of chopping the hell out of a plant—usually a shrub, sometimes a tree—but (BUT!) doing it well, in such a way that it will automagically grow back better than ever.
I adore renovation pruning, and I believe it may be as hereditary as it is incendiary. My mother adored it before me, and her mother before her.* If scientists could successfully isolate the gene for renovation pruning, we could produce armies of better mow and blow guys.
*I sometimes took issue with what they chose to renovate, but then people have taken issue with my renovations, and like my predecessors, I didn’t care — that sucker was coming down.
Witness: my home’s “foundation plantings” before I got ahold of it.
Is this not the picture of ennui? I’m fatigued just laying eyes on it.
I find many foundation plantings (gosh, there’s a term that makes me snicker) like mine are ripe for renovation. Yews and hollies were cut to the ground, and all but one returned. Rhodie and beautybush were tamed from lions to lambs. We said sayonara to a variegated euonymus, a plain green one, a forsythia and a burning bush, some sad candytuft, and some lawn. And then, I planted, and I planted, and I planted some more. This is my garden (yes, I think now it’s best characterized as a garden) on renovation. This is quite often what I do at clients’ homes. To that end, to me, renovation is one of the great joys of gardening.
Should you ever you find yourself in need of the Renovator, you know where I live.
Read more about renovation and restoration from my fellow GDRT bloggers!
Carolyn Gail Choi : Sweet Home and Garden Chicago : Chicago, IL
Genevieve Schmidt : North Coast Gardening : Arcata, CA
Jocelyn Chilvers : The Art Garden : Denver, CO
Lesley Hegarty & Robert Webber : Hegarty Webber Partnership : Bristol, UK
Rochelle Greayer : Studio “G” : Boston, MA
Susan Cohan : Miss Rumphius’ Rules : Chatham, NJ
Susan Morrison : Blue Planet Garden Blog : East Bay, CA








[...] Andrew Keys : Garden Smackdown : Boston, MA [...]
Very nice renovation! I have grown to hate the term foundation planting, it has the same feel as “half a garden”, so snicker understood.
Extra bonus: I learned a new word to use - ennui!
Completely different approach from Sir Smackdown!
That garden looks completely different too - good on you!
Best Wishes
Robert
PS Beautifully written as ever. Never any ennui in your posts!
Andrew,
Great job, I love the finished product. I’m may be one of the few people who likes yews, but only when they have that unclipped, slightly wild look. Renovation pruning is one of those jobs I am somewhat hesitant about undertaking although I have a few Ilex crenata in my ‘foundation plantings’ that could use some help.
Why do people hack indiscriminately at shrubs? “…huuuhhh, aren’t ya spos’da prune these things?” Stop the abuse, people!
Andrew,
I love what you did. It’s so soft, creative, textured, loose, colorful, and fun. I can just see some of the plants swaying in the wind. Nice job!
Love the renovation! You have a kindred spirit in my husband when it comes to renewal pruning. He thinks the best way to tame an out of control Burford holly is with a chain saw—-and at our house, he would be right.
[...] Andrew Keys : Garden Smackdown : Boston, MA [...]
Those blobby amoebic bushes make my chest tighten….
I love when I can convince people to take the radical pruning approach — the best argument never ceases to be that you have nothing to loose….if it dies, oh well, it sucked anyway, and if it lives, there is a good chance it will come back better.
I’m so grateful for the second set of pictures…I can breath easier….
In my neck of the woods it’s the juniper meatballs / amoebas that have to be eradicated! Lovely new garden you’ve created—renewal, indeed!
Thanks for commenting, guys! It’s been a labor of love, that’s for sure. It’s nowhere near finished, but when are these things ever finished? I AM glad you’re all in agreement that it’s an improvement.
What a transformation. What I like the best is that you didn’t REMOVE you renovated what was useful and gave them new neighbors. The only thing I find disconcerting is the shade loving rhodies with the sunloving grasses…but if it works well then…do it.
@Susan C: That’s a really good point re: the rhodie! If it hadn’t already been there, I’d have never planted it, it’d be a bitch to take out, and frankly we don’t have enough evergreens as it is. It’s counterintuitively happy too. And it’s on the south corner of the house! Go figure. I hate it when it blooms, though. LIVID magenta. LIVID, I tell you!
Nice job!
So, how do you prune an ilex? I have an enormous one that I hate in a place in my backyard that would make a nice spot for some veggies, frankly, and I desperately want to dig it up, along with two huge arborvitae that I wish would crumble to dust.
Andrew, I just love the “afters”. So soft, loose, and relaxed - yet gorgeous.
I must say though, I LOVE livid magenta. I look fantastic in it and so do my gardens.
@Hope: Hey! I think it would depend on the Ilex. In general, small-leaved hollies like these (Ilex crenata) I’m not afraid to totally cut to the ground. Larger-leaved ones, like Maggie’s Burfords, I might be a bit more conservative about, only because I’ve never renovated one. I’d probably try to confirm with a bit of research it was OK to do before I did that. If yours is a crenata type, though, I’d chope it. I’d do a bit of research on the arborvitae too — they’re slow-growing enough that, if they’re big enough, I might limb them up instead of cutting them down so they can return anew.
@Gen: Thank you! I can love most any color in the right context, but let me assure you, this livid magenta sticks out like a sore thumb when it appears, and it will burn holes in your retinas.
I think the deer have “limbed up” my arborvitae already, but I’ll try it. And that does it, I’m taking the ilex down! (rather than out) Thanks!
I like that you chose to save your butchered evergreens rather than automatically rip them out. (Not that there’s anything wrong with ripping out under-performing plants.) Crepe myrtles are often butchered with over-pruning here in the South, and they can be renovated by chopping them to the ground too and letting them regrow into the graceful trees they’re meant to be. People can be scared to do it, but it works like a charm.
Wow, what a dramatic difference, Andrew. Like many, I have a bit of pruning-phobia, even though I tell my clients not to worry so much, most plants will bounce back even if they’re pruned harder than they prefer. I guess I need to put my money where my mouth is and get out the pruning sheers in my own garden!
I like the transformation, and the picture captions had me laughing. Why do people think the best pruning tool is hedging shears?
I’m a pruning ‘fraidy cat, I must admit. I admire those of you who can prune harsh and swift, with a confident smile on your face. But when I actually prune like I’m supposed to, I’m rewarded with a happy and healthy plant. I need to toughen up, for sure. I love your transformation, also. It’s really, really beautiful.
A bush-wacking fool much like myself. The before and afters are amazing. Great renovation.
Thanks, all!
@Carolyn: Bushwhacking! YES!
@Rebecca and Susan: You and one Ms. Gervais have that in common, it would seem. ;-)
@Liz: Hey, thanks for commenting, and I’m glad to hear someone mention the captions!
@Pam: YES! I know MANY a crape that could’ve been cut where I grew up.
@Hope: Best of luck with your own bushwhacking!
[...] Andrew Keys : Garden Smackdown : Boston, MA [...]
You’re welcome to come and renovate my monstrous yew hedge to your heart’s content. (I’m sure it irked you the entire time you visited me…) I’m too chicken that it won’t come back! Great post, as usual!
Oh, and I must say, as much as I admire your ability to renovate rather than rip out, one of the most satisfying moments after we bought our house was hooking an over-pruned yew to the back of the pickup and pressing on the gas pedal…
@Michelle: Ha! Well, thanks! But wait, what I’m really wondering is how did the Salix ‘Hakura-nishiki’ I pruned at your house do the rest of the season?
(My one curly willow cutting that survived seems to have pulled through, BTW.)
It’s doing great! Despite no rain. The doublefile viburnum nearby is reminding me of Droopy Dog…
@Michelle: Droopy Dog! I forgot about him! Well, I hope Droopy Viburnum is happy with the rain today.